I feel in love with this pattern as soon as I saw it.
http://www.canadianliving.com/crafts/crochet/crocheted_v_neck_pullover.phpI bought the book then bought the yarn and then got my friend, who is a dressmaker, to measure me. The pattern state that if you don't want a figure hugging jumper then to go up a size. I did a gauge test and even did a swatch test with the contrasting colour.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0c966/0c966602314a58088a9e226de906ad64903d37fe" alt=""
I did that and realised by the time I got to the underarms that it was way to big, so I frogged it and started again. The size down is written poorly. There are quite a few pattern row that simply don't work. I doubt it was tested once typed out, because one of the rows is obvioulsy half missing. Having already started the size up I improvised those rows. The whole way through I had one extra pattern repeat which is about an inch to inch and half (American pattern). Now I have measured it and it is about an inch - inch and half bigger than it is supposed to be, but on me it feel huge. I still need to do the sleeves and the neckline.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/52171/521711c01a2ab6938d1d059f5db0621195e0e1b9" alt=""
It doesn't look too bad right?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/97ec8/97ec8ab24799d2b072dc8f3bef09c749ab4a047c" alt=""
Again, not too bad right?
Hello? Can you see the extra material now?
OK, now here is me holding at least 6 inches in at the back?
Does it look better or is this going to make me look fatter?
And that is my grumpy face! LOL
Now looking at these pictures I am thinking it doesn't look that bad, but it does feel huge. I think I should frog it and start again a size smaller, but this would be a size smaller than my measurements as well. I seriously think that won't be a problem because there is a lot of room in this one. Anyway I need your help! Does it look huge and would I be better to frog the lot?Another alternative would be to go back to the hip shaping and take that out. It would save about 4 - 6 inches, but I worry that it would look boxy.
Can anyone give me some advice please?